General Discussion

intrepidity

(8,296 posts)

43. You're saying a suit needed to be filed to .... what?

Reply to Fiendish Thingy (Reply #41)

Mon Jun 9, 2025, 08:29 PM

18 hrs ago

Prove that the law existed or was violated?

Seems you might amend your post #11.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

58 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Guard call up is invalid- they can be held personally responsible. [View all] James48 Yesterday OP

Will TACO taco or will he pardon all the troops, or will he double down? Get popcorn out! marble falls Yesterday #1

Double Down JustAnotherGen 11 hrs ago #48

Gavin needs to communicate this directly to those soldiers. Javaman Yesterday #2

I recommend the protestors print that and hand them out to the National Guards. Doodley Yesterday #3

I recommend blunt-nosed paper airplanes HariSeldon Yesterday #14

Love it! FailureToCommunicate Yesterday #24

Yes! If only they could be dropped from upper story windows, like confetti parades. FailureToCommunicate Yesterday #23

I doubt this matters, since when have laws stopped Trump? dem4decades Yesterday #4

He is losing lots of court cases MadameButterfly 22 hrs ago #33

I think the goal is to let the Guardspeople know--they don't have spooky3 Yesterday #5

So far, I've only seen LA police roughing up anyone. In fact, other than National Guard around detention center, not Silent Type Yesterday #6

and I doubt they WILL do much of anything. There's hardly any protest. No rioting. LymphocyteLover 7 hrs ago #50

The convict doubled down even worst by calling up Marines, active duty troops... brush Yesterday #7

The Insurrection Act of 1807 applies here Kaleva Yesterday #18

What insurrection? LearnedHand 6 hrs ago #52

A friend was an officer in the Army in Vietnam. He was ordered to go into Cambodia, armed with a camera and surfered Yesterday #8

If they are smart (Which I believe they are) HarryM Yesterday #9

Charge who? For what? reACTIONary Yesterday #10

Clearly, you are mistaken Fiendish Thingy Yesterday #11

Thank you, although if past is prologue on DU, this misinfo OP will rack up 100+ recs. Celerity Yesterday #13

A lie travels around the world... Fiendish Thingy Yesterday #15

as predicted, 122 recs and counting Celerity Yesterday #27

+1 Kaleva Yesterday #17

Why "clearly." The OP clearly infers Newsom's likely position; so what if it doesn't mention Newsom. You're ancianita Yesterday #19

It's not a strawman argument Fiendish Thingy Yesterday #22

It is you that are clearly mistaken. W_HAMILTON 19 hrs ago #40

Indeed, that is the law quoted in Newsom's suit Fiendish Thingy 19 hrs ago #41

You're saying a suit needed to be filed to .... what? intrepidity 18 hrs ago #43

The suit *alleges* that particular law was violated Fiendish Thingy 15 hrs ago #46

I'm confused Bluesaph 14 hrs ago #47

The governor doesnt sign off DetroitLegalBeagle 7 hrs ago #51

Was that done? Did they follow the procedure? Bluesaph 1 min ago #58

So if not properly activated, they are held personally accountable? Would they then be held on Scalded Nun Yesterday #12

False. nt LexVegas Yesterday #16

Gavin seems to be growing a pair. He can throw down the gauntlet and have the CA Guard commander flashman13 Yesterday #20

Trump Mblaze Yesterday #21

Or something like that. intrepidity 18 hrs ago #44

"My evidence refuting the OP's claim is that Newsom (and the AG, and other legal experts) have not made this claim.)..." ancianita Yesterday #25

I didn't "call out people's facts as opinions" Fiendish Thingy 19 hrs ago #42

Grabber Blue Ozarks Yesterday #26

Before the Civil War, that was correct Polybius Yesterday #28

NYTimes had an article on it yesterday - TBF Yesterday #29

I have a paywall remover link Polybius Yesterday #30

The question is intrepidity 18 hrs ago #45

In that case it looks like LBJ was trying to protect marchers - TBF 5 hrs ago #54

This is not accurate! It's dangerous misinformation. Please edit/remove. LauraInLA 22 hrs ago #31

Are you not aware that Trump federalized this shit specifically so he could do this? Because it sure sounds like it. Karasu 22 hrs ago #32

Prosecute them all. Moostache 22 hrs ago #34

arrest them under state law moonshinegnomie 21 hrs ago #35

All nice but who's doing anything about it? Firestorm49 21 hrs ago #36

Does California need to build it's own military Fullduplexxx 21 hrs ago #37

They already have one basically DetroitLegalBeagle 3 hrs ago #57

Wikipedia is your friend... progressoid 20 hrs ago #38

Guest on Nicolle Wallace said the same thing. Katinfl 19 hrs ago #39

And will the remedy be remedied? William769 9 hrs ago #49

How does the fed have authority to send NG troops to Iraq? JohnnyRingo 6 hrs ago #53

Title 10 DetroitLegalBeagle 3 hrs ago #56

K&R bdamomma 5 hrs ago #55