General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region Forumsreminder about "orders"
If you are an active member of the national guard or the US military and are ordered to violate the constitutional rights of anyone on US soil, call the GI Rights Hotline. You swore an oath to support and defend the US constitution and do not have to follow unlawful orders.
877-447-4487

Clouds Passing
(5,060 posts)SheltieLover
(69,418 posts)
SheltieLover
(69,418 posts)
Silent Type
(9,839 posts)to Henchman First Class in trumps military.
regnaD kciN
(27,084 posts)but I have a hard time imaging a Guardsman, upon receiving an order to move on protesters, pulling out their cellphone and asking the CO to wait a minute while they call to check.
Initech
(105,132 posts)
LogDog75
(489 posts)Military members have the right to question unlawful orders and the right refuse to obey obviously illegal orders. The problem being is the average military member doesn't have knowledge or training to determine whether an order is legal or not.
An obvious illegal order is to pull a demonstrator off the street and execute them and I hope they would refuse the order. In the case of the demonstrations in LA., the National Guard take orders from the governor and from the president when he nationalizes the Guard. It's up to the leaders of the Guard to make the determination as to whether the orders from the governor or the president are lawful and provide their troops with the appropriate guidance.